Monday, September 13, 2010

Breaking Out of Self-Induced Molds

While I understand preference, and each person is certainly entitled to their own taste, I have heard a lot of statements about what people will and won't try lately that make me cringe. I also have to say that as I watch those that are open to new experiences, I certainly see people who have more fun. This is true in wine as well. There is such a diversity of what one can buy and drink out there that completely eliminating broad categories is really a loss to the individual. This post is dedicated to the idea of branching out, revisiting what it is that you think you do not like. Below are some things I hear frequently that make me cringe, and my suggestions to combat the preconceived notions that are really only limiting to your own experience:

"I don't drink white wine" - I'm not sure if this is primarily driven from a fear of residual sugar, or the idea that white wine is inherently feminine. Both of these are blatantly false. My suggestion for someone who thinks they do not like white wine is to try a dry Australian riesling, like St. Hallett Eden Valley Riesling. The wine is crisp, slightly complex, and bone dry. While it is nothing like the profile of a red wine, it surely can be appreciated for its food worthiness, and interesting flint components.

"I hate Chardonnay" - I don't know if this comes from an aversion to oak flavors, or extra rich profiles, but to dismiss chardonnay out of hand is short sighted. Chardonnay is such a popular grape because it is so receptive to a winemaker's influence, thus there are many profiles that chardonnay takes on. Try C. Donatiello's 809 Clone Chardonnay for a more citrusy, almost spicy flavor profile that will show you a side of chardonnay you may not have experienced before.

"I don't drink California wine" - This one makes my blood boil. I think it is supposed to sound sophisticated, but to me it just sounds arrogant. I'm okay with someone saying that they don't drink overripe, high alcohol wines that are not balanced. It is okay to feel that you want to spend your money on food friendly, earthy wines, with great acidity. But you can find those in California as well. For my money I'm going with the Ridge Buchignani Ranch Carignane. Some may balk and say that there is still quite a bit of fruit forwardness to this wine, and I say 'yes' because I want to show that California wine (even in its own style) has a place on the dinner table, and below 14% alcohol. This wine is no fruit bomb, very drinkable, with great earthy elements.

"I don't care for any sweet wines" - If this comes from your diabetes, fine. But if it comes from a fear of bottom shelf domestic riesling, lambrusco, or white zinfandel then you have the wrong idea. You must splurge and try something like NW Totem Cellars Late Harvest Viognier. Don't drink this with dinner, drink it as a dessert. The aromatics and tropical fruit explosion is truly enjoyable. Please, it is not a replacement for your dry wines of choice, but will show you not to fear the sweet.

What wine 'absolutes' have you heard that you just know are limiting people, putting themselves into their own boxes? What recommendations do you have for those who only limit themselves?

9 comments:

  1. I agree that these generalizations cause people to miss out on some very exciting wines.

    I'd rather hear people say they are focusing on getting to know Santa Barbara Pinots better, or Russian River Syrah, for example.

    I'll admit that I don't really understand Pinot Noir yet, though I'd like to. That means everything from fine Burgundy to Syrah-blended CA style. There is such a range in tastes between those regions alone.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Jon. I think good Pinot does take some figuring out, if you want to. Then again some of us probably over think wine in general. It's okay to sometimes just drink what you like because you simply think it tastes good.

    ReplyDelete
  3. :)
    I ONLY care for sweet wines... :)
    Does this make me more or less diabetic?

    always love your take!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I would say it makes you close-minded, but I know better ;)

    You my dear should not be drinking ANY wine from what I hear. Thanks Sarah.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great topic. I've. Wondered the same thing about generalized statements regarding wine. I also believe it's ann issue of openness and experiences, I can remember a time when all I liked was pinot.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Nice post as always, Scott. We've learned to open our palates to just about anything out there. There are clunkers in just about every category; but there are some fantastic wines, too. The one I'd add is don't be unwilling to try fruit wines or wines made from Hybrid grapes... Chambourcin, Norton, Traminette et al all can make interesting and good wines.

    BTW, Scott, we opened the Anglim Mourvedre last night. Fantastic! Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Daniel, so would you admit that you never really only liked pinot, just only allowed yourself to believe you liked pinot? BTW, what a funny little grape to be stuck on, huh? Just kidding.

    Chris, now there is a suggestion that I need to be open to. Any ideas about finding a hybrid grape wine I should try? I'm so glad you enjoyed the mourvedre. I'm saving the cab to get a little age on it.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hybrid grape wines are common in many of The Other 46. My most exposure has been in the midwest, IL/OH/IA/MO/TN, and Virginia/North Carolina. I'm hoping at WBC'11 there will be some hybrid grape representation, or you can seek it "on the side", but even the Virginia winemakers I've talked to seemed to be downplaying the hybrids in favor of vinafera. It makes them seem more like "real" wineries I'd guess.

    Where to find them for shipping to CA is a difficult proposition I think. One Virginia winery where we like their Chambourcin and a Blend called Fossil Hill is Cave Ridge, but they don't have on-line ordering. I know they shipped wine to WA to us though, so it might be worth a call if you can't wait til next summer.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks Chris. I ironically am probably going to get to drink a Baco Noir (hybrid) from Southern Oregon with my dad today. I was talking to him about it last night and we agreed that it might be worth opening with the BBQ pork sandwiches and OSU Beaver football game this afternoon. I'll report back on here when I do my upcoming Southern Oregon week.

    ReplyDelete